Hollywood icon Sharon Stone just dropped a surprise gem about her dating history, and it involves none other than rapper Nelly.

During her appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, Stone shocked fans when Cohen asked point blank:

“Sharon, did you go on a date with Nelly?”

With a smile, Stone admitted:

“Yes, I did.”

The revelation left Cohen and guest Bob Odenkirk stunned, with Cohen calling it, “crazy enough that I actually might believe it.”

When pressed on whether a second date followed, Stone confessed, “No, I did not.” She didn’t give details on when or where the date happened, leaving fans with nothing but curiosity (and a ton of “what ifs”).

The news quickly sparked reactions online, with fans joking about the unexpected pairing and calling them “star-crossed lovers who could’ve been.” Even though the romance didn’t blossom, this unexpected Hollywood-hip-hop crossover is one for the books.